In light of yesterday's post about changes at Etsy, I'm raising this topic now: At what point do you consider something to be handmade?
I ask this as one of my customers read the post yesterday and brought the question to me regarding beauty products, and whether sellers that exclusively use pre-made wholesale-purchased bases to be handmade. Rather than re-craft an entirely new article (sorry, I'm a bit lazy and have some soap going right now!), I'm going to post my response:
There are a LOT of gray areas in handmade. One one end of the spectrum,
there's this: At some point, you can't do every single aspect yourself.
If you were a woodworker, for example, you may not be the one cutting
down the tree and breaking it down into planks. If you knit, you most
likely don't raise your own sheep, harvest the wool, process it into
your own yarn, and THEN knit. Then on the other end, you have jewelry
"makers" that take a store bought charm and put it on a store bought
chain and call it handmade. Or the bath and beauty makers that buy
bases, throw in some fragrance, and call it handmade. That's the other
extreme.
I think distinguishing factors need to be:
1. Did you reinvent the items in some way to make them unique?
2. Did you create an entirely new product with the components you used?
If the answer to both is yes, then I think that falls under handmade.
Applies very well to bath and body - there are SO many sellers using
bases straight-up, and then so many that use them as a starting point,
add all sorts of new ingredients, and then "reinvent" them into
something new, and then also so many working totally from scratch. The
last two, I would consider to be handmade. But, there is no way to sort
those people out from the "quickies" in the marketplace in a fair way.
Way back, when I first started, using the pre-made bases was what got
me interested, and I'm sure it is for many people because they are so
easy to use and really inexpensive. It's designed to be a home project.
But if you're really into the creating aspect, it gets boring really
quickly! And, the end result is a fairly cheaply-made product, and
customers can tell the difference.
Essentially, the customers,
like yourself, will weed out the bad products. If you buy from someone
and you're not happy, you're not going back to buy from them again and
it stinks for you, as a buyer. And those sellers are the ones that are
always crying on Etsy, asking why their stuff doesn't sell or why they
don't have repeat buyers. But no one ever has the guts to tell them the
truth. For sellers like myself, the best thing we can do is try to get
our name out there, try to get our product in more people's hands, and
hope for the best. Because if our product is good, customers DO come
back, and buy more, and tell their friends and family and neighbors how
awesome this cool thing they bought on Etsy was. But it takes a long
time to weed out the bad from the good, and every day there's just as
many bad shops popping up as there are amazing, brilliant new sellers.
I really do appreciate that you love everything you've gotten from us,
and that you keep coming back! It means more to me than I can explain.
Some nights I'm up until 4 a.m. cranking out whipped soaps and lotions
by hand with my little $20 hand mixer until I'm about to pass out - it's
just me doing everything, with some little bits that my husband does,
and that is with me working full-time also. But, I LOVE what I do and I
wouldn't give up all the hard work that goes into it for anything. The
money I make back is just a perk that lets us do fun things, like go out
to dinner, or on a family day trip, or pays for my son's homeschool
books, etc. Every sale on Etsy is a huge big deal.
So thank
you, thank you, thank you! I'm sure I sent back a much bigger response
than you expected, but there's so many aspects to consider that it took
me a bit to explain.
I would love to hear comments and thoughts on this - please feel free to post here!